Survivor Cagayan was one of the best season's ever. With so many interesting players, it begs the question, which ones should come back to play again? Well, I say there were so many great players from that season they should all be brought back in the same season, with the exception of Lindsey. Quitters don't deserve to come back. As the title of this article suggests it could be called Cagayan 2: The Rematch!
However I don't think they should be divided into the same three tribes, which would be pretty much impossible anyway without Lindsey there. I say they should start off with 2 tribes with Tony and Woo being the captains of each tribe and allowing them to choose their own tribes alternating in their picks with Tony getting first choice since he came in first. Also alternating between guys and girls.
Of course without Lindsey they would start off with an uneven number so what to do about that? Bring someone else in from a past season? No! Bring one of the loved ones in from the final episode? No! I say start off with 17 players after Tony and Woo choose their 7 tribemates, exile the last person left over until the first immunity challenge. They did something like this in Figi with the odd man out replacing the first person voted off, but I didn't really like that. I think the tribe that loses the first challenge should still be at a numbers disadvantage so I say the tribe who loses the first challenge in Rematch should have to vote out 2 people and then whoever was exiled would join that tribe giving it 7 tribe members to the other tribes 8.
A lot of people probably think the Kass would be the odd man out but I don't think so. I think if Tony were smart she would probably be his first choice. Tony would naturally have a HUGE target on his back and Kass would be one of the few people who could take the heat off of Tony. It would still be highly unlikely for Tony to make it to the end but I think aligning with Kass would be his only shot. I think Ja'tia would actually be the most likely candidate to not be picked.
So would anyone else like to see Spencer Tony Kass and Tash battle it out again? Of course I would love to see Morgan back again. View the video below for my tribute to Ms. Mcleod.
